Showing posts with label Corporate Responsibility. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Corporate Responsibility. Show all posts

Monday, June 01, 2015

Business in the Public Interest

Business in the Public Interest


"Government and industry were never intended to be natural adversaries. The mission of business is to create value for shareholders, to do right by employees, to respect and contribute to the communities where it operates, and to deliver quality goods or services to the market. If it does these things with a sense of purpose and vision, the greater good and the public interest will be well served, and the public will regain trust in the inherent value of business in our society.There is no reason why government and industry cannot work separately, but in sync, to address the compelling issues in society that affect us all."


--Adonis Hoffman, Esq.
Founder & Chairman
Business in the Public Interest

Monday, July 15, 2013

What is Responsible Business Conduct, Anyway?


In the face of widespread corporate scandals on Wall Street, President George Bush ushered in what he called a "new era of corporate responsibility." Of course, the president's message accompanied the passage of Sarbanes-Oxley, along with a spate of regulation designed to compel more transparency into the practices of financial services companies.

Today, those practices are governed by the sweeping Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform Act (Dodd-Frank), which established the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB).

Mr. Hoffman discusses the sweeping
 implications of Dodd-Frank legislation
with Sen. Chris Dodd in Washington 
And it is that very CFPB which has set out to define and determine, what constitutes responsible business conduct--at least with respect to the behavior it is authorized to enforce.  Thus, in late June 2013, the CFPB issued the following guidance for all to behold and abide by:

Self-policing:
This concept, which can also be described as self-monitoring or self-auditing, reflects a proactive commitment by a party to use resources for the prevention and early detection of potential violations of consumer financial laws. 

Self-reporting:
While no substitute for effective self-policing, self-reporting substantially advances the Bureau’s protection of consumers and enhances its enforcement mission by reducing the resources it must expend to identify potential or actual violations that are significant enough to warrant an enforcement investigation and making those resources available for other significant matters. Prompt self-reporting of serious violations also represents concrete evidence of a party’s commitment to responsibly address the conduct at issue.

Remediation:
When violations of federal consumer financial laws have occurred, the Bureau’s remedial priorities include obtaining full redress for those injured by the violations, ensuring that the party who violated the law implements measures designed to prevent the violations from recurring, and, when appropriate, effectuating changes in the party’s future conduct for the protection and/or benefit of consumers. Remediation may be viewed positively even when the party believes that it may have identified a potential rather than an actual violation. 

Cooperation:
Unlike self-policing and remediation, which may occur with or without Bureau involvement, cooperation relates to the quality of a party’s interactions with the Bureau after the Bureau becomes aware of a potential violation of federal consumer financial laws, either through a party’s self-reporting or the Bureau’s own discovery efforts. In order to receive credit for cooperation in this context, a party must take substantial and material steps above and beyond what the law requires in its interactions with the Bureau. Simply meeting those obligations will not be rewarded by any special consideration.

Following these steps will help the CFPB determine the level of responsibility a company has adopted, and accordingly can help the agency mitigate practices harmful to consumers.



Tuesday, February 19, 2013

Governance Challenges for Today's Board of Directors

In a recent McKinsey Quarterly article, William George, a former CEO of Medtronic, and a veteran of ten corporate boards, reflected on common governance pitfalls and how to overcome them. McKinsey Quarterly 1Q 2013

The recommendations offered by Professor George are valuable given his wealth of experience in key roles as a director with leading companies.

I especially appreciate the advice to independent directors to step outside their own spheres of influence to learn more about the business or industry of the company. Of course, this is often easier said than done, given time demands and the speed at which business happens and board decisions must be made, but it invariably will make those directors function more efficiently, and will deepen their commitment to the duty of care expected of all directors.
One area Professor George neglected to mention, but I consider important, is the board’s interaction with outside advisors. Outsiders can be instrumental in prudent board decision-making, especially in pre-IPO or pre-merger deliberations, times of crisis, on compensation matters, and even on succession planning. How directors deal with the advice and strategies presented by these external experts often determines success or failure of the task(s) at hand.
Finally, no review of governance or board performance would be complete without some discussion of the value of including diverse directors in the boardroom. Here, I am referring to ethnic diversity, which continues to be an oft-cited, yet elusive, aspiration for most corporations. Companies, especially those which are consumer-facing, should be guided by the evolving demographic landscape of North America, and indeed the globe, which reveals a preponderance of consumers of color. In addition, our global economy has spawned a new set of corporate expectations. Companies operating internationally should be acutely aware that the totality of their corporate activities are viewed through a new prism—a prism with such facets as human rights, environmental stewardship, fair labor, diversity, inclusion, and sustainability, among other corporate responsibility indicators.
Embracing these new market realities and societal mandates through enlightened corporate policy is both a beacon and a benchmark of responsible companies.
These decisions, rightfully, begin and end with the board. Leading CEOs understand the inter-relationship between the new realities and the advancement of shareholder value, and seek directors who can credibly balance these often competing interests.
(c) 2013.  Adonis E. Hoffman

Monday, September 10, 2012

Hard Assets On The Line

Glencore, the world's largest commodity trader,  is seeking to merge with Xstrata, a global leader in coal and mining, to form a post-merger company to be valued at nearly $90 billion.  Latest bid .  The proposed merger would become the biggest deal of the year, involving (literally) tons of hard assets.  When we consider the magnitude and impact of this deal, it is hard not to look askance at the other big deal of the year--Facebook.  There, hard assets were tough to quantify in the face of massive valuation estimates. No such problem here, as Glencore's reach expands to aluminum, coal, sugar, grains, and crude oil.  It could not be more brick and mortar.

I don't know what Xstrata's record is on the environment, labor, or human rights.  But as putative partners in one of the biggest mergers of the year, both Glencore and Xstrata might want to shore up their compliance on non-financial matters, which are always problematic in the commodities and extractive sectors. Glencore's IPO was the largest ever on the premium listing of the London Stock Exchange, and this deal will make it an even higher profile target for activists. Plus, the company's provenance as a spin-off from Marc Rich & Company increases its mystique quotient.  A few smart steps by CEO Ivan Glasenberg today can bring reputational, as well as financial, success for the new company going forward tomorrow.

--Adonis Hoffman is a corporate advisor, professor and attorney in Washington, DC. He is the author of Doing Good--The New Rules of Corporate Responsibility, Conscience and Character.


Friday, September 02, 2011

Ikea's $62 M Pledge for African Relief is Leadership In Deed

When Ikea announced its foundation would send $62 million to help the victims of the Kenyan famine, the world's largest furniture chain reached another milestone. Ikea's pledge is the largest private donation to go to a UN relief agency in the agency's 60-year history.  At a time when national governments and transnational corporations seem impervious to the suffering in that region, Ikea's business leadership speaks volumes through its deeds. Critics have taken on the Swedish company over labor and supplier matters. But if Ikea's commitment to salve the human condition is any indication of its character as a company, the other issues should be easily solved.

Friday, December 03, 2010

Hooray for Huggies

It has been a long time since my two kids were in diapers, so I do not pay attention to anything remotely related to babies' bottoms. Thus, although it is not a new story, I was surprised and impressed to learn that Huggies has a national campaign which donates diapers to needy families. The background is here.

Huggies, of course, is a well-known brand of disposable diapers made by Kimberley-Clark. The arrangement seems to be simple and straightforward: for every diaper purchased by consumers, Huggies will donate a diaper to a designated diaper bank in the U.S. Needy families can go to a diaper bank and receive ample supplies of clean, new, disposable diapers.

Why is this so good?

Apparently one in three moms in America cannot afford to buy enough diapers for their children. Most daycare centers require a full day's supply of clean diapers. If a family cannot provide the required complement of diapers, the child cannot attend daycare. Beyond that, a recent study found that many needy moms throughout America are washing and re-using disposable diapers because they cannot afford fresh ones. Yes, in America, this simple convenience escapes many in need.

Huggies campaign to meet this need by allowing customers to contribute and participate suggests a level of corporate responsibility not manifest in many organizations. The company saw a need, and designed an innovative, simple solution that goes a long way to solving the problem.

To be sure, the cynics among us will point out that Huggies is in the business of selling diapers, and the more goodwill they develop through this campaign will help them sell more diapers. Well, yeah. In a capitalist, free-market economy, the first order of business is to profit. If a company can master that feat, it can turn its attention to helping society by combining its core business with a good cause.

It seems the folks at Kimberley Clark and Huggies have mastered this balance. They have done well and are doing good. Hooray for Huggies.

(c) 2010

Friday, November 12, 2010

Better Business Bureau Needs Oversight Following Charges of Pay-to-Rate

The Better Business Bureau could benefit from tighter government oversight following recent allegations that it has maintained a pay-to-rate scheme for years.

For decades, the Better Business Bureau has been the gold standard for the validation of solid business practices. We all rely on the BBB's ratings system to determine whether a company is worthy of our dollars or not. To learn now that the BBB might have been scamming us all this time is heartbreaking. If these charges are true, it is betrayal at the most basic level. If these charges are true, and I hope they are not, the Federal Trade Commission needs to take a long hard look at how to cure the damage that has been done to consumers.

The other problem here is that the Better Business Bureau manages several industry self-regulatory schemes. These include the very successful program guarding children's advertising to the newly-developed program to monitor the marketing of so-called junk foods by 16 of the top food and beverage manufacturers, and the monitoring of infomercials. While those programs are self-contained, the BBB's actions cast a very dark cloud over the practice of self-regulation altogether.

In the interest of consumer confidence, the FTC needs to take a much closer look at the BBB--a consumer icon that may have fallen on the wrong side of the ethical line.

(c) 2010. Adonis E. Hoffman

Monday, January 25, 2010

Not Above the Fray--Corporations Contribute Dollars and Deeds to Haiti

As the sad news of devastation and despair in Haiti recedes from the national headlines, there is an enduring good news story not receiving its due: corporations have taken the mandate of global corporate citizenship to higher and unprecedented levels.

The early aftermath of Haiti's earthquake found national governments and international NGOs hastening to the aid of the suffering masses in the western hemisphere's poorest nation. We all expect developed countries and organizations like the Red Cross to spring into action when there are major crises. Corporations, we assume, would be supportive, if at all, with dollars but not with deeds.

But after a series of hurricanes, earthquakes, tsunamis, famines and other natural disasters over the last two decades, the corporate sector has changed the script and heightened our expectations. Our society can now reasonably expect corporations--large and small--to play an active and indispensable role in international relief efforts. This assumed duty stands in stark contrast to the all-too-familiar dirge of corporate scandal, misdeed and malfeasance, and is the latest step along the continuum of responsible corporate citizenship.

Remarkably, a healthy level of competition has ensued. One company after another has been spurred on by the charitable efforts of its corporate rivals. While the commercial contests among companies to dominate market share in goods and services will and should continue, it is good to see that the competition to give more time, talent and treasure to help relieve human suffering has become an entrenched pillar in the corporate landscape. In fact, those companies who, for whatever reason, fail to show up, become spotlighted by their breach.

As we enter the second decade of the second millennium, the societal mandate for corporations to do good has fully matured. While we may cringe when a company toots its own horn too loudly, or carp that corporate profit should inure more fairly to society's needy, let us at least celebrate the commitment of many, many companies to be not above the fray.

(c) 2010. Adonis E. Hoffman.

Mr. Hoffman is a lawyer in Washington, DC and is the founder and chairman of the American Business Leadership Institute. He teaches Corporate Responsibility at Georgetown University.

Wednesday, July 22, 2009

Fiduciaries Need to Proactively Raise Corporate Responsibility Matters

As the global financial crisis moves into maturity, it is clear that novel solutions must be found to a novel set of problems. The United Nations Environment Programme Finance Initiative(UNEP) proffers such a new approach.

According to its most recent report, investment advisors have a fiduciary responsibility to proactively raise environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues, in addition to other financial matters.

KEY HIGHTLIGHTS OF THE REPORT:

* The global economy has now reached the point where ESG issues are a critical consideration for all institutional investors and their agents.

* Investment consultants and asset managers have a duty to proactively raise ESG issues within their advice and services to institutional investors.

* ESG issues must be embedded in the legal contracts between institutional investors and their asset managers to hold asset managers to account, and that ESG issues should be included in periodic reporting by asset managers. Equally, the performance of asset managers should be assessed on a longer-term basis and linked to long-term incentives.

* Institutional investors will increasingly come to understand the financial materiality of ESG issues and the systemic risk they pose, and the profound long-term costs of unsustainable development and the consequent impacts on the long-term value of their investment portfolios.

* Institutional investors will increasingly apply pressure to their asset managers to develop robust investment strategies that integrate ESG issues into financial analysis, and to engage with companies in order to encourage more responsible and sustainable business practices.

* Policymakers should ensure prudential regulatory frameworks that enable greater transparency and disclosure from institutional investors and their agents on the integration of ESG issues into their investment process--as well as from companies on their performance on ESG issues.

* Civil society institutions should collectively bolster their understanding of capital markets such that they can play a full role in ensuring that capital markets are sustainable and delivering responsible ownership practices.

* Market incentives that reward long-term investment must be made to help create responsible and sustainable capital markets that would help identify future challenges in the financial system, reduce the chances of further crises and help avert a "Natural Resources Crisis"--and accelerate the transformational process to a green, inclusive and sustainable global economy.

It will not be long before corporate directors, as fiduciaries, should have to play by the same rules. Stay tuned. . . .

(c) 2009 Adonis E. Hoffman

Wednesday, July 15, 2009

Technology, Society & Corporate Responsibility

In a thought-provoking article in Information Week entitled, "Can Tech Companies Do the Right Thing?", Michael Hickins points out that some technology companies who have been held up as model corporate citizens in one continent are being castigated as bad actors in another.

He is referring to the recent allegation by Iranian protesters that Nokia--by use of its advanced technology by the Iranian government to spy on and track demonstrators--is complicit in the denial of basic of human rights to Iranians.

The irony, Hickins points out, is that Nokia recently was lauded as a leading socially responsible company for all of its good work in the U.S.

What this all suggests to me is that norms of corporate behavior can be adjusted to fact-specific situations and cited as either positive or negative.

Moreover, technology, which is normally thought of as a neutral tool (or force) that can be utilized for good or evil, may not be so innocent. I hesitate, though, to jump to the conclusion reached by the Iranian democracy dissidents that mere usage of a technological tool by a repressive regime, renders the technology inherently bad.

In their earnest efforts to draw international condemnation on the Iranian government, the democracy demonstrators have directed their wrath in the wrong direction.

(c) 2009 Adonis E. Hoffman

Monday, July 13, 2009

Responsibility of the Faithful

Faith-based socially-responsible investors generally, and those in the Catholic faith particularly, have not always been welcome voices among the chorus of corporate responsibility activists. But that is changing.

Occasionally shrill on the issues, these conscientious monitors remind us that there is more to the call for socially-responsible investment than the usual list of do-good stakeholder demands. Dare we say they are truly focused on how companies do business and how those business decisions will affect the whole of society.

Thus, Sister Patricia Daly of the Sisters of St. Dominic, who is director of the Tri-State Coalition for Responsible Investment should be commended for her principled stance on environmental and governance issues.

It is hard to argue with an order that takes a vow of poverty, chastity and obedience--and still finds room to make money for their investors.

(c) 2009 Adonis E. Hoffman

Wednesday, July 01, 2009

Has Corporate Responsibility Reached a Plateau?

If we believe the recent results of an IBM annual survey, it would appear that corporate responsibility in practice may have reached a plateau.

In a recent article in Forbes, two IBM execs point out that across the globe, managers are committed to sustainable practices, but don't always do the necessary follow-through. I've re-published the salient comments and advise you to read the findings for yourself.

"IBM recently completed its second annual survey of senior executives around the world asking them how they are handling green and sustainability issues in their corporate strategies. The results are encouraging in some respects, but they show how very far businesses still need to go to truly be on the road to sustainability.

"The overwhelming majority of the 224 respondents said they are committed to incorporating principles of corporate social responsibility into their business strategies--despite the global recession--as a way to improve their business performance, their contribution to society and their reputation. Some 60% said this was more important to them than a year ago; only 6% said it was less."

"And businesses, for the most part, are no longer just paying lip service to sustainability. They're trying to optimize their operations to reduce environmental impact and improve social effects while also improving business performance.

"But our survey shows a significant gap between the business and sustainability goals companies are setting for themselves and what they are actually doing to attain them. And information is at the heart of the problem.

"Specifically, our survey findings show that:

--Companies aren't collecting and analyzing the information they really need or aggregating it often enough. Because of that, they can't implement real changes to fundamentally increase efficiency, lower costs, reduce environmental impact and improve their reputations with key stakeholders.

--Few are collecting enough data from their global supply chain partners, so they're missing major opportunities to reduce the inconsistency, inefficiency, waste and risk that can ripple through a global supply network.

--Most still don't understand the concerns of their key stakeholders, particularly customers, and they're not actively engaging them to find out. That means they're missing out on knowledge that could improve their businesses and lead to new opportunities."

I suppose that means there's still a long way to go.

(c) 2009

Wal-Mart's Everyday Responsibility

As a company known for "everyday low prices", Wal-Mart has not exactly been known as a champion of corporate responsibility, primarily due to its employment and benefits policies that seem to shortchange employees in terms of healthcare coverage.

Whether that reputation is earned or not is debatable; what is indisputable today, though, is that Wal-Mart's tune has changed.

Along with the Service Employees International Union (SEIU) and the Center for American Progress, Wal-Mart--the nation's largest employer--has endorsed the so-called "employer mandate" which requires businesses to provide health insurance coverage in a letter to President Obama.

As Obama called for a new era of responsibility in his inaugural address, it looks as if the guys in Bentonville were listening. Bravo!

(c) Adonis Hoffman 2009

Monday, May 25, 2009

The Power of Social Responsibility

I could not agree more with Lisa Hickey, the former president of the National Association of Women Business Owners, who wrote an op-ed for the Lakeland, FL. Ledger.

She points out that in our pursuit of profitable business, we should not overlook the power of social responsibility.

In fact, the point that corporate responsibility can differentiate a business and lead to customer preference is more of a hard business rationale than any "do-good" notion.

And finally, there is the timeless observation by Bill Gates, that the pervasive power of business is to execute change through innovation and competence as creative capitalism.

(c) 2009. Adonis Hoffman



Thursday, February 26, 2009

Whither Good Works

The global economic recession has precipitated enormous changes in the way business conducts itself. One of the more unfortunate consequences has been a retrenchment by corporations on their good works, philanthropy and volunteerism.

To be sure, fiscal prudence dictates that companies must put their own financial homes in order before extending helping hands to others. Few major corporations are so flush with hard cash that they can continue to operate at the same pre-recessionary levels.

And yet, amidst this crisis, there are those companies that continue to contribute to society and mankind in ways that are nothing short of admirable. Pfizer's Patient Assistance programs come to mind as reflecting the kind of help big corporations need to provide to those in need. As does Johnson & Johnson's Access to Medicines programs that gave away 2.3 million units of medicine to over 300,000 people across the globe. In the mega-buck world of pharmaceuticals and medicine, these are two companies that appear to be leading the way on what it means to be good corporate citizens.

There are other examples out there across the industrial landscape. My recommendation is that we continue to look for the good works that companies are doing, if for no other reason than it makes the world better and makes us all stand a bit stronger. For the cynics out there who say this is meaningless corporate blather, I suggest you visit the dusty streets of Yaounde, Cameroon or the crowded slums outside Lusaka, Zambia for a firsthand view of the impact of free medicine on the life of those who are in need.

Monday, January 07, 2008

Influence Others to Do Good

“There is but one rule of conduct for a man to do the right thing. The cost may be dear in money, in friends, in influence, in labor, in a prolonged and painful sacrifice, but the cost not to do right is far more dear: You pay in the integrity of your manhood, in your honor, in strength of character; and, for a timely gain, you barter the infinite.”
--Archer G. Jones


Competition not only is good for business, it is good for society. When one company sees its competitors behaving responsibly, its own competitive instincts get into gear, especially when those competitors are being rewarded and recognized in the marketplace as is often the case.

In the same way as a company establishes itself as the pacesetter for an entire industry, it can lead the way in other areas. I am reminded of organizations such as Levi Strauss, Johnson & Johnson, and Starbucks who, by their consistent examples, have prompted their industry competitors to strive to do good things.

Corporate leaders set positive examples for others to follow. All too often, corporations are influenced by the wrong kinds of actions—spiraling executive pay, more and more perks for the board, and stupendous stock grants—while many of the basic issues that matter to their customers go overlooked.

True corporate leadership propels a company to influence others to make lasting investments in underserved communities, to take extraordinary measures to preserve the environment, and to promote sustainable development throughout the world, for example. Doing well, alone, is never enough. A corporate leader must seek to do good for others, too.

(c) 2008 Adonis E. Hoffman

Tuesday, January 01, 2008

The Buck Stops With You

"You are not here merely to make a living. You are here to enable the world to live more amply, with greater vision, and with a finer spirit of hope and achievement. You are here to enrich the world. You impoverish yourself if you forget this errand."

Woodrow Wilson, 28th President of the United States

Harry Truman epitomized responsibility in a chief executive. His now famous words, “the buck stops here,” became part of the national lexicon and changed the way Americans viewed their leaders. “The Buck Stops Here” became an instant euphemism for responsible leadership.

President Truman’s sense of accountability and his acceptance of responsibility for the actions of his administration fundamentally changed the way all chief executives were to be viewed from that point forward. It was a classic lesson in the principle that responsibility begins at the top.

In today’s business environment, leadership must come from the top. CEOs and key executives should establish the tone for the rest of the company. That’s why they’re paid the big bucks. If your name is at the top of the organization chart, like or not, you are responsible for just about everything that happens below.

CEOs, directors, and senior executives are expected to provide leadership in every facet of corporate affairs, recognizing that their employees, shareholders, investors, and customers will be judging their actions.

(c) Adonis E. Hoffman, 2007.

Sunday, December 30, 2007

The Challenges of Today's CSR 3.0

We are in the early stages of an era that I like to call "corporate responsibility 3.0."

The first and longest stage of modern corporate responsibility was characterized by companies developing codes of corporate conduct, CSR initiatives and socially responsible investing (SRI). It was, in essence, a feeling out period to determine whether corporate responsibility had staying power.

CSR 2.0 was ushered in by Sarbanes-Oxley and was largely a response to well-documented scandals, abuse and corporate misbehavior.

In today's new era of CSR 3.o, the corporate sector faces the challenge of independence. Consumers and customers are increasingly independent-minded in their purchasing decisions. Investment capital is increasingly independent as private equity plays a larger role. And new regulatory mandates have convinced shareholders that public companies need to be guided by independent directors with little connection to the companies.

As higher profits abound in some sectors--energy, financial services, and technology, more companies will have to figure out how to make their contributions to society consistent with the new requirements of CSR 3.0.

(c) 2008 Adonis E. Hoffman